Ukraine: It’s not about Europe vs Russia

SOURCE: The Spectator
By John Laughland

    

To discuss the Ukrainian crisis in terms of a choice between Europe and Russia is misleading for several reasons.

First, the European issue has been ruthlessly exploited by the Ukrainian opposition and its Western backers as an excuse for overthrowing the government illegally and by force. Opposition leaders have never distanced themselves from the most radical elements on the streets of Kiev, even though these include neo-Nazis. On the contrary, they have done everything to use their violence as a bargaining chip in their battle with the government. Let us never forget that the majority of the 25 deaths on the night of 18 – 19 February were murders committed by the protesters: 9 policemen were shot dead or stabbed to death, while 3 members of the governing party and a journalist were also killed.

Second, the choice Ukraine faced between the EU and Russia was not an equal one. The EU association accord was a comprehensive political straitjacket designed to lock Ukraine into the orbit of Brussels and Washington by installing, as all over the EU itself, a pro-EU (and ultimately pro-NATO) elite whose policies would remain unchanged whichever team was in power. By contrast, Ukraine’s agreements with Russia are confined to a free trade zone and, lately, loans. They carry no internal political implications at all. Even the Customs Union of Russia, Kazakhstan, Belarus and Armenia, which Ukraine will probably not now join, takes decisions by consensus: it has none of the heavy-handed supranational and technocratic control of Brussels.

Third, Ukraine did not really have a choice. Thanks to decades of corrupt politics, the Ukrainian state is bankrupt. So is the EU. In spite of stringing Kiev along with pretty words about a European future, the EU could offer only $800 million , via the IMF, and that came at the price of exceptionally painfully economic reforms. Ukraine would have been subjected to the same devastation of its agriculture, on which it depends, as Romania and Bulgaria were in their pre-accession period. Its industry would have collapsed as well. Russia, by contrast, has been able to offer nearly 20 times this sum in loans to prevent Ukraine from becoming insolvent, and it is the biggest market for Ukrainian exports – bigger than the whole of the EU put together. Moreover, Europe’s coffers are empty for good reason: her member states are drowning in their own debt, while the economic vice turned on its own member states – Greece, Spain and others – has plunged those countries into misery. Russia, by contrast, has tended to run balanced budgets while her growth ticks along at 4% or so, against Europe’s anaemic 1%. Trade in the Customs Union has grown by 40% in 5 years. Ukraine’s signature on the EU association agreement (the one Georgia signed runs to 400 pages) would have been the longest suicide note in history.

To avoid facing up to its own inexorable decline, the post-modern EU, like the United States, has plunged ahead with a radically anti-Russian geopolitical and ideological agenda based on left-wing fantasies about resurgent nationalism in Moscow. We used to laugh at Cold Warriors but the absurd anti-Russian ravings of Dr Strangelove and Jack D. Ripper have now become the standard fare served up in Washington and Brussels. What a shame most of the Western media swallows this rubbish.

2/24/2014

See also
Acting Ukrainian president is a pastor and its prime is a scientologist Acting Ukrainian president is a pastor and its prime is a scientologist Acting Ukrainian president is a pastor and its prime is a scientologist Acting Ukrainian president is a pastor and its prime is a scientologist
Supreme political posts in Ukraine are occupied by people connected with not traditional for the country religious organizations.
Bishop Philaret of Lvov: Bishop Philaret of Lvov: "The voice of the church remains unheard. May the Lord guide our lives Himself"
Bishop Philaret of Lvov and Galicia
Bishop Philaret of Lvov: Bishop Philaret of Lvov: "The voice of the church remains unheard. May the Lord guide our lives Himself"
The following address of His Eminence Bishop Philaret of Lvov and Galicia to his flock has been issued in connection with the events in the Ukraine.
Snipers shooting at policemen in Kiev, 20 injured Snipers shooting at policemen in Kiev, 20 injured Snipers shooting at policemen in Kiev, 20 injured Snipers shooting at policemen in Kiev, 20 injured
More than twenty law-enforcement agency officers were injured on Thursday as a result of the sniper's shooting on the Maidan Nezalezhnosti ("The Independence square") in Kiev.
Ordinary Patriotism Ordinary Patriotism
Lado Gegechkori
Ordinary Patriotism Ordinary Patriotism
Lado Gegechkori
"Orthodoxy in the Ukraine" published this interview with the monks from Desyatina Monastery in Kiev, who stood between the police and the protesters in late January, stopping the violence for at least a few days through their prayer and example.
Men in Black Men in Black
Dimitry Sokolov-Mitrich
Men in Black Men in Black
Dimitry Sokolov-Mitrich
The “Chaotic Pendulum” is a very funny thing. When you throw it off balance it flounders comically in space like a mad geometrical cripple, or a supremacist construction. It’s an enchanting sight, like the gaze of a boa constrictor.
Havoc unleashed: Footage shows Ukrainian rioters brutally assaulting police Havoc unleashed: Footage shows Ukrainian rioters brutally assaulting police Havoc unleashed: Footage shows Ukrainian rioters brutally assaulting police Havoc unleashed: Footage shows Ukrainian rioters brutally assaulting police
Disturbing footage from Ukraine shows violence spiraling out of control during anti-government protests, with rioters attacking and capturing policemen standing their ground. The Interior Ministry has hinted at a tough response if the unrest continues.
Comments
louis hemmings4/15/2014 11:47 pm
9 policemen 3 members of the governing party (which one is that??) one journalist killed also means that 12 Euromaden were also killed. that's about equal by my maths!

can the Kiev protesters really "all" be nazis?? are "all" Christians in the west pro Euro / USA? are all Russian Orthodox swallowing Putin's fascist propaganda? of course not.

as Christians, i would have thought it your calling from God Almighty to be impartial and to not bear false witness, as the Holy Scriptures command.

your bias shows! tuck it in, at least....

Slava Tebey Gospody!
Harrison J Krenitsky2/25/2014 1:53 am
One should not assume that all coming from the East is bad. Likewise, one should not assume that all coming from the West is of “Good.” Nationalism, ethnicity and culture, whether from the east or west, have become a divisive weapon used for geo-political and geo-economic agendas. It is a weapon that benefits the few and generally harms the innocent majority.

Sadly, the Truth is constantly ignored by both sides in order to achieve selfish and mostly personal agendas. The Orthodox Church stands against Phyletism because Phyletism divides people, even those of the same religious persuasion. As Truth is of God, politics flows from hell and is made up of deceptive nationalism, ethnicity, and culture mixed in with economic greed! While politics corrupts all three, the Truth in Christ transfigures and brings all three into unity. How sad it is that we all have missed and continue to miss the mark of Love and Peace.

My prayers are with the innocent victims and people of the Ukraine.

May the Peace of God be with both.
Irina2/25/2014 12:47 am
Way to go! Well done!
Here you can leave your comment on the present article, not exceeding 4000 characters. All comments will be read by the editors of OrthoChristian.Com.
Enter through FaceBook
Your name:
Your e-mail:
Enter the digits, seen on picture:

Characters remaining: 4000

Subscribe
to our mailing list

* indicates required
×